Have you ever tried to force yourself not to think about something, only to find it consuming your thoughts even more? Or attempted to “make” your partner feel differently, only to create more distance between you?
Welcome to one of the most liberating psychological truths you’ll ever encounter: You cannot control your internal experience, but you absolutely can manage it. And when it comes to others? You have even less control than you think (but more influence than you realize).
Let’s dive into why this distinction matters, especially for your emotional well-being, your relationships, and yes, your sex life.
The Critical Difference: Managing vs. Controlling
Think of your thoughts and feelings like weather patterns. You can’t control whether it rains, but you can absolutely decide whether to bring an umbrella, seek shelter, or dance in the downpour.
That’s the difference between managing and controlling.
What Does “Managing” Your Internal Experience Look Like?
Managing is about skillful response, not forceful suppression.
When you manage your thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, you’re working with your natural human experience, not against it. Here’s what that looks like in practice:
- Acknowledgment: “I’m feeling anxious right now” instead of “I shouldn’t feel this way”
- Curiosity: “What is this feeling trying to tell me?” instead of “Make it stop immediately”
- Skillful action: “Given this feeling, what’s the most aligned choice I can make?” instead of “I must eliminate this feeling before I can act”
The core belief: Your thoughts and feelings are temporary signals—messengers, not masters. They don’t define you, but they do deserve your attention and skillful handling.
What Does “Controlling” Your Internal Experience Look Like?
Controlling is about forceful suppression and internal warfare.
When you try to control your internal states, you’re essentially telling yourself that certain thoughts and feelings are unacceptable. You’re at war with yourself. This looks like:
- Suppression: “Don’t think about that. Stop feeling this way.”
- Self-criticism: “What’s wrong with me for feeling jealous/anxious/turned on by this?”
- Mental force: Trying to “think positive” your way out of difficult emotions
- Rigidity: “I should only feel X in situation Y”
The core belief: Thoughts and feelings are threats or personal failures that must be immediately eliminated or changed.
Why Control Backfires (Especially in Your Sex Life)
Here’s the paradox: The harder you try to control your internal experience, the more out of control you feel.
Psychologists call this the “rebound effect” or “ironic process theory.” Tell yourself not to think about a white bear, and suddenly that’s all you can think about.
In Your Sexual Life, This Shows Up As:
Performance anxiety: “I must get aroused. Why am I not aroused yet? What’s wrong with me?” (The pressure kills arousal)
Shame spirals: “I shouldn’t have that fantasy. Good people don’t think this way.” (The shame intensifies the thoughts)
Disconnection from pleasure: Constantly monitoring yourself—”Am I wet enough? Hard enough? Turned on enough?”, instead of being present in the experience
Rigid sexual scripts: “Sex should always look like X” instead of responding to what feels good in the moment
The Management Approach to Sexual Thoughts and Feelings:
- Non-judgment: “I’m having this fantasy. That’s interesting. It doesn’t mean I have to act on it.”
- Curiosity about arousal: “What does my body need right now to feel safe and open?”
- Responsive behavior: “I’m not fully present today. I can choose to pause or communicate that to my partner.”
- Flexible scripts: “What would feel good for both of us right now?” instead of following a predetermined “should”
When you manage (rather than control) your sexual thoughts and feelings, you create space for authentic desire, pleasure, and connection.
The Bigger Illusion: Trying to Control Others
Now let’s talk about the even more impossible task: trying to control another person’s thoughts, feelings, or behaviors.
Here’s the Truth Bomb:
It is completely irrational to believe you can manage or control what goes on inside another person’s mind or heart.
Every person you meet, especially your partner, possesses complete cognitive and emotional autonomy. Their inner world is:
- Built from their unique history and biology
- Interpreted through their personal lens
- Completely inaccessible to you
- Non-negotiable by external force
You cannot make someone:
- Stop feeling jealous
- Feel attracted to you
- Stop having intrusive thoughts
- Desire you sexually
- Feel secure in the relationship
Their internal experience is not your responsibility. And frankly, it’s not within your power.
But Here’s What You Can Do: Influence Through Healthy Communication
While you cannot control another person, you absolutely can influence their behavior, especially in intimate relationships.
The key is understanding the difference between influence and control.
Influence Looks Like:
Clear communication of needs: “When you check your phone during our intimate time together, I feel disconnected. I need your full presence to feel safe and open.”
This is managing the interaction, not controlling their feelings about phones.
Setting boundaries: “If you continue to pressure me for sex when I’ve said I’m not in the space for it, I will leave the room to protect my own well-being.”
This is a statement about your behavior in response to theirs, not a demand that they change their internal state.
Expressing impact: “When you make jokes about my body during sex, I shut down arousal-wise. I need affirmation or neutral language to stay present.”
This educates them about consequences while respecting their autonomy.
Control Looks Like:
- “You need to stop feeling insecure.”
- “Just be more confident.”
- “You shouldn’t be attracted to other people.”
- “If you loved me, you’d want sex more often.”
See the difference?
Influence respects autonomy and creates space for connection. Control violates autonomy and creates resentment.
The Rational Relational Conclusion
Here’s what healthy people in healthy relationships understand:
- You are only responsible for managing your own thoughts, feelings, and behaviors
- You can influence others through clear communication, boundaries, and modeling
- Attempting to control your partner’s internal states (jealousy, desire, insecurity, attraction) is a direct path to relational dysfunction
- The only person you can truly change is yourself
When you stop trying to control yourself and others, and start skillfully managing your own experience while influencingthrough healthy communication, everything shifts.
You become more emotionally resilient.
Your relationships become more authentic.
Your sex life becomes more connected and pleasurable.
You stop fighting battles you can never win.
Quick Reference: Are You Managing or Controlling?
With Yourself:
Managing: “I’m feeling anxious about sex tonight. Let me check in with my body and communicate what I need.”
Controlling: “I shouldn’t feel anxious. What’s wrong with me? I need to force myself to relax right now.”
With Your Partner:
Influencing: “When you criticize my performance, I lose arousal. I need encouragement or silence to stay present.”
Controlling: “You need to stop being so critical. Just be more positive. Why can’t you just support me?”
The Bottom Line
Your thoughts and feelings are not your enemies. They’re information.
Your partner’s thoughts and feelings are not your responsibility. They’re theirs.
What you can do is:
- Skillfully manage your internal world with acceptance and awareness
- Clearly communicate your needs and boundaries
- Influence through healthy relating, not forceful control
This is the path to emotional freedom, relational health, and a sex life that feels authentic and alive.
Ready to Dive Deeper?
If this resonates and you’re ready to work through patterns of control (of yourself or others) that are showing up in your relationships or sexual life, I’d love to support you.
As a sexologist and relationship therapist, I help individuals and couples move from control to management, from rigidity to flexibility, from shame to acceptance.
Book a consultation at Love and Intimacy by Erin and let’s explore what skillful management of your inner world, and healthier influence in your relationships, could look like for you.
You deserve emotional freedom. You deserve relational authenticity. And you absolutely deserve a sex life built on presence, not pressure.
Let’s talk.
What resonated most with you in this article? Have you noticed yourself trying to control rather than manage? I’d love to hear your reflections in the comments below. 💭
Stay Connected: Get More Insights on Intimacy & Relationships
Love this content? There’s more where this came from!
📬 Subscribe to Substack
Get weekly insights on emotional regulation, relationship health, and sexual wellness delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe on Substack for exclusive articles, tools, and community discussions.
📺 Watch on YouTube
Prefer video? I break down complex topics like managing vs controlling emotions, attachment styles, and intimacy challenges on my YouTube channel. Subscribe here for new videos every week.
